home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=94TT1685>
- <title>
- Dec. 05, 1994: Cover:Leadership-Where Are They Now?
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1994
- Dec. 05, 1994 50 for the Future
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- COVER/LEADERSHIP, Page 68
- Where Are They Now?
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p> The legends-to-be were all there when we named future leaders
- in 1974 and 1979--Bill Clinton, Dan Rather, J. Stanley Pottinger...J. Stanley Pottinger?
- </p>
- <p>By James Collins
- </p>
- <p> So where have they led us, yesterday's leaders of tomorrow?
- In the summer of 1974, shortly before Richard Nixon became the
- first President ever to resign, TIME, perceiving a crisis of
- leadership in America, presented its "Faces for the Future,"
- 200 men and women, age 45 and under, who could "assume leadership
- roles in the right circumstances--and given the right spirit
- of the country." Five years later, TIME chose a new portfolio
- of "faces for the future"--50 more people in the same age
- category whom the editors identified as emerging leaders. Without
- seeming immodest, we may observe that we accurately predicted
- great futures for many of the individuals on our lists. We made
- some missteps, of course--Marion Barry comes to mind--and
- we did fail to notice some of those who were in their pupal
- leadership stage--Newt Gingrich, say--but the fact remains
- that we did pretty well. Nevertheless, we do find one question
- just slightly troubling: If the future leaders we chose were
- so great, how come we're still searching for leaders? William
- J. Clinton, as he was formally identified by TIME, made our
- leadership list in 1979--he was 32 years old and the country's
- youngest Governor. However honored he may have been at the time,
- today he might not be particularly pleased by the example we
- provided to illustrate his ability to take courageous action
- and make others follow: "Instead of cutting taxes like everyone
- else," we wrote, "Democrat Clinton persuaded the assembly to
- raise them by $47 million."
- </p>
- <p> We also put former Massachusetts Senator Paul Tsongas on that
- '79 list, and if things had gone differently in 1992, he might
- have been the first person we would be mentioning here, relegating
- William J. Clinton to a passing reference as the Arkansas Governor
- who finished second in the New Hampshire primary. What did we
- think was important to tell readers about Tsongas 15 years ago?
- For one thing, that he "has strongly supported the Kennedy-Waxman
- national health-care plan." After the events of this past year,
- "the Kennedy-Waxman national health-care plan" has such a quaint
- ring to it.
- </p>
- <p> None of the leaders on the 1974 list has become President as
- yet--but that's not for lack of trying. Twenty years ago,
- who would have imagined that H. Ross Perot, then a 44-year-old
- founder of a computer-software company, would win 19% of the
- vote as a third-party candidate in the 1992 election? George
- Bush-nemesis Pat Buchanan, a 35-year-old Nixon aide, made the
- 1974 list, as did presidential aspirants Jack Kemp, then 38
- and a two-term Congressman, and Joseph Biden, at 31, the Senate's
- youngest member. As for perennial presidential almost-aspirant
- William Bradley, who in '74 was 30 years old and still a Knick,
- we wrote that he "was laying the groundwork for a possible congressional
- bid in his New Jersey district with public speaking between
- games and in the off-season." If public speaking was his strategy,
- it's remarkable that Bradley had any political career at all.
- </p>
- <p> Remember that Kennedy-Waxman national health-care plan? In 1974
- we said one of its sponsors could "practically write his own
- ticket--including a presidential one." Edward M. Kennedy was
- 42 back then, and we wrote that "Teddy's recent trip to the
- Soviet Union and Western Europe, plus his well-publicized sponsorship
- of health care legislation and an income tax cut, may be the
- opening shots in a bid for the White House." That bid actually
- came in 1980--and went.
- </p>
- <p> It almost seems as if everyone on the 1974 list has run for
- President at one time or another. Jerry Brown made the roster,
- and his presidential bids came in 1976 and 1980 and again in
- 1992. Former Governor of Florida Reuben Askew ran in 1984, and
- Lamar Alexander, Secretary of Education in the Bush Administration,
- looks like he's trying for the 1996 G.O.P. nomination. Pete
- du Pont, the ex-Governor of Delaware, challenged Bush in the
- primaries in 1988, as did Donald Rumsfeld, Gerald Ford's Secretary
- of Defense; and Congresswoman Pat Schroeder was an undeclared
- candidate in 1988. Given this pattern of presidential ambition
- among the '74 selectees, we should not be surprised if Robert
- Gottlieb, the former editor of the New Yorker, or Saul Steinberg,
- the onetime greenmail virtuoso, begins showing up at lunch counters
- in New Hampshire next year, chatting with the citizenry.
- </p>
- <p> There is more to leadership than dropping out of the primaries
- just after Super Tuesday, however. Marian Wright Edelman, mentor
- of Hillary, then and now director of the Children's Defense
- Fund, was named in 1974. So was Dan Rather, coming off an excellent
- season of confrontational Watergate-related press conferences
- with President Nixon; Rather replaced Walter Cronkite as the
- anchor for the CBS Evening News in 1981 and has remained in
- the job, solo or accompanied, ever since. Another television
- journalist, Barbara Walters, then 43, also made the 1974 list.
- TIME called her "TV's first lady of talk," and if she has ceded
- that title to Oprah Winfrey, she remains an institution--TV's
- first first lady of talk. Jann Wenner's name appears two places
- below Walters'; the 28-year old founder of Rolling Stone was
- then known to his staff as "Citizen Wenner," we reported. That
- year his publishing interests grossed $6 million; for 1993 the
- figure was more than $100 million. When another magazine editor,
- R. Emmett Tyrrell Jr., was chosen in 1979, he was 35 and ran
- an irreverent, relatively obscure, right-wing monthly called
- the American Spectator; now, with a rich subject like Bill Clinton
- to sustain it, the American Spectator's circulation has grown
- to 10 times what it was in 1979, and conservatives treat its
- editor as if he were Rush Limbaugh crossed with George Bernard
- Shaw.
- </p>
- <p> Unfortunately, for some of those identified as future leaders,
- things have not gone so smoothly. Gary Hart was listed in 1979,
- and we quoted this comment Barry Goldwater made about him: "You
- can disagree with him politically, but I have never met a man
- who is more honest or more moral." Another '79 alumnus was Marion
- Barry, whom we quoted thusly: "I think integrity is the most
- important quality for a leader." At the time, Barry was the
- mayor of Washington. Forced out in 1990, he has just been returned
- to office, which suggests a new definition of leadership: it
- is the ability to inspire, to command and to get re-elected
- even though you have been videotaped smoking crack in a Washington
- hotel room with a woman not your wife.
- </p>
- <p> Peter MacDonald, former chief of the Navajo Nation, could be
- found on the 1974 list; now he can be found in a federal prison
- in Bradford, Pennsylvania, where he is serving 14 years for
- charges relating to bribes and kickbacks. When Harold Greenwood
- was chosen as a future leader in 1974, he was president of something
- called the Midwest Federal Savings & Loan in Minneapolis. Had
- we known then what we know now about S& Ls, we might have been
- able to guess that in 1991 he would be convicted of fraud. Molecular
- biologist David Baltimore was 36 when TIME selected him for
- the 1974 list; the following year he won the Nobel Prize for
- Medicine, and in 1990 he became president of Rockefeller University,
- an ultra-prestigious research institution. But 18 months later,
- he resigned as a result of a scandal over data falsified by
- one of his researchers at Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
- Robert Sanchez, the Archbishop of Sante Fe, made our 1974 list.
- He was accused of having sex with several women and resigned
- in 1993. Of all the 250 former future leaders, however, Richard
- Ravitch may have achieved the greatest ignominy. He appeared
- on the 1974 list on account of his work as president of his
- family's construction firm and his civic activities. Today he
- is the chief negotiator for the major league baseball owners.
- </p>
- <p> Yet it is not the future leaders who ended up disgraced that
- cause concern; it is the leaders who were successes. TIME was
- prescient to identify Les Aspin in 1974 as someone who might
- go far. Back then he was simply a two-term Congressman with
- an interest in military affairs, yet he rose all the way to
- Secretary of Defense. How well did that turn out? Clinton, Rather,
- Biden, Senator Sam Nunn, columnist George Will, California Governor
- and possible Republican presidential nominee Pete Wilson, lawyer
- Alan Dershowitz, Citibank CEO John Reed--all were on the lists
- of potential leaders, and all could be said to have realized
- their potential. Even so, the leadership vacuum remains. We
- have the leaders we wanted. Now what?
- </p>
- <p> (Oh, and as for J. Stanley Pottinger: in 1974 he was a Nixon
- Administration lawyer. He eventually retired from public service
- and worked in investment banking and real estate, suffering
- occasionally from the vicissitudes of the marketplace. His first
- novel, The Fourth Procedure--a thriller--will be published
- in April.) He has no plans to seek national office at this time.
- </p>
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-